The U.S. Government

Because democracy only works when we understand it

An illustration of a vast gray city square under searchlights, where ranks of uniformed marchers file past armed guards, tanks, a towering monument, and red banners reading Unity, Order, and Order Over Freedom
Government through Stories: Totalitarianism

The Windows, the Neighbors, and the Town Made of Glass

A town with thick walls and busy clubs gives up one window for safety. Then a glass door, then glass walls, until there is nowhere left to stand.

Political system7 minute read

The Windows, the Neighbors, and the Town Made of Glass

Imagine a town called Linden, where every house has thick walls, curtains on the windows, and a front door that locks from the inside.

Linden is a republic. Its people elect a council, and the mayor can serve only two terms. The town's constitution, kept in a glass case at the town hall, says that a family's home is its own, that people may meet, worship, and speak as they please, and that no one may be punished for what they believe.

Outside the houses, Linden is full of things nobody planned. There's a chess club in the back of the bakery, a choir at the stone chapel, a carpenters' union, a Saturday football league, and two newspapers that disagree about almost everything.

Nobody is in charge of all of it.

Children used to learn the constitution in the seventh grade: why the walls are thick, and why the clubs belong to their members. Then the lesson was cut to make room for test drills. Nobody complained. The walls had always been there. Why study them?

Then come hard years. The mill closes. A fire at the grain store is blamed on saboteurs. People are frightened, and they stop asking, "Does the constitution allow it?" They ask only, "Will it keep us safe?"

How the Unity Party won every office in Linden is a story of its own. This one starts the morning after, when a party that holds the town hall decides that isn't enough.

The first order is small. Every house must cut one window into the wall facing the street, so the night watch can see that all is well.

"A family that loves Linden," says the Party, "is glad to be seen loving it."

Ah, it's only one window. (Privacy.)

And it works. Burglaries drop. Mothers let their children walk home after dark. A widow on Mill Lane says she has never slept so well.

But the night watch is only forty men, and Linden has three thousand windows. So the watch asks for help. A neighbor who notes who visits whom gets an extra coal ration. A coworker who repeats a joke heard at lunch gets a promotion. Nobody announces who has said yes. Everyone knows that some of their neighbors are writing reports, and no one knows which ones (informers).

Next come the glass front doors. Groups that meet behind closed doors are suspicious, the Party says, so the chess club, the choir, the carpenters' union, and the football league are closed. The Party opens its own: the Unity Chess Circle, the Unity Choir, the Unity Workers' Front. The members are mostly the same people. The songs are not (independent associations).

The two newspapers become one, the Linden Unity Herald, and it agrees with itself about everything (a free press). The chapel stays open, but a Party officer sits in the back row and takes notes during the sermon (freedom of worship).

The children join the Lantern Youth. It's free, there are summer camps and brass bands, and most of the children love it. At their first meeting they learn about Little Tomas, a brave boy who told the watch that his own father was hiding grain, and who was killed for it by his angry relatives. There is a statue of Tomas in the square now. The teachers ask, kindly, what parents talk about at dinner.

Marta, a seamstress on Bell Street, notices that her son Pim has stopped asking questions at the table. So has she.

Then the cards appear. Every door gets a small painted card: gold, gray, or black. Gold families get the apartments near the square, the jobs at the town hall, and university places for their children. Gray families wait. Black families, whose grandfather once wrote for the wrong newspaper, are moved to the cold houses by the quarry, and their children stop school after the eighth grade. The color passes from parents to children like a family name (equal treatment under the law).

The town chronicle is rewritten. The years before the Party become "the Years of Disorder." Old newspapers vanish from the library, and a former councilman who fell out of favor disappears from the photograph of the new bridge's opening. The word "free" is painted on banners everywhere, but now it means free of disorder (an honest record of the past).

The constitution is still in its glass case, every word unchanged. Nobody reads it.

One evening a polite man from the watch visits Marta. Pim's school is choosing who goes on to the academy, he says. It would help if Marta wrote a little each month about her neighbor Helga, who used to sing in the old choir. Nothing much. Who visits. What she says.

Marta thinks of Pim. She says yes. She tells herself she will write only harmless things, and mostly she does. Pim goes to the academy.

By now, the walls of every house might as well be glass. People keep their curtains open, because closed curtains get noticed. They cheer at the parades and grumble nowhere. They learn to wear two faces: one for the street, and one they keep so far inside that sometimes they forget it's there (freedom of conscience).

There is no wall left to stand behind.

So when the Party does something that many people hate, nobody can meet to talk about it, because every club is the Party's. Nobody can write about it, because every newspaper is the Party's. Nobody can say it at work, or at the chapel, or even at the dinner table in front of a child. Each person is alone with the thought, and one person alone with a thought can't do much.

And still, many people in Linden say life is good. Everyone has a job. Rents are low. The streets are clean and the parades are splendid. Gold-card families do very well, and plenty of gray-card families truly believe in the Party.

Many years later, the glass finally cracks. Crowds fill the square, too many for the watch to stop, and they walk into the watch house itself. They find rooms full of folders, one for nearly every family in Linden.

The new council passes a law: anyone may read their own folder, and learn the real name of anyone who wrote about them.

Helga reads hers. She finds Marta's careful handwriting, month after month. Marta wrote mostly about the weather, the price of thread, and how often Helga watered her roses.

The town historian opens one more folder, the one about Little Tomas. Almost none of the story was true.

Helga sits with her folder for a long time. Then she walks to Bell Street and knocks on Marta's door, which is made of wood again.

The Party never needed to watch everyone. It only needed everyone to believe they were being watched, and to take away every place where people could stand together and say no.

A town made of glass doesn't have to break a single door. It only has to make sure nobody closes one.

The Real Lesson

This story isn't claiming that every police patrol, government record, or school club is a step toward tyranny. Towns need police, records, and schools. Nor is it claiming that the people who went along were villains. Most were ordinary people, like Marta, trying to protect their families, and many honestly believed in what they were told.

The real issue is reach. An ordinary dictatorship wants control of the government. A totalitarian state wants control of everything else too: the job, the school, the choir, the chapel, the dinner table, and finally the thoughts people keep to themselves.

Look at what protected Linden before the Party reached them: thick walls, a chess club, a choir, a union, a chapel, and two quarreling newspapers. None of them belonged to the government. That is exactly why they mattered. They were places where people could trust each other, think out loud, and act together without asking permission.

And notice how few watchers it took. The night watch was small. It ran on neighbors, coworkers, and children, each making one small, reasonable-seeming choice for a good reason.

The real lesson is this: privacy, independent groups (churches, clubs, unions, a free press), and freedom of conscience are not extras a free country can trade away for safety. They are safeguards themselves. A government that controls every part of life leaves nowhere to stand to resist it.

Where That Road Led

East Germany's Ministry for State Security, the Stasi, was founded in 1950 and called itself the "shield and sword of the Party." By 1989 it had about 91,000 full-time employees and about 189,000 unofficial collaborators, roughly one for every 90 citizens, who reported on their colleagues, friends, and fellow pupils (Stasi Records Archive).

On December 4, 1989, citizens in Erfurt occupied the local Stasi office to stop files from being destroyed, and on January 15, 1990, crowds entered Stasi headquarters in East Berlin. The Stasi Records Act of December 20, 1991, in force on December 29, let every person read the file kept on them from January 2, 1992, and ask for the real names behind informers' code names. More than 1.5 million people have seen their files (Federal Archives).

In North Korea, the UN Commission of Inquiry reported on February 7, 2014, that the state had committed crimes against humanity, and that it found a state that "does not have any parallel in the contemporary world." It found that the songbun system, a class rank assigned by birth and loyalty, had long decided where people live, what work they do, whether they reach university, how much food they get, and even whom they marry (UN document A/HRC/25/63).

In the United States, the First Amendment protects religion, speech, the press, and the right to assemble, and the Fourth Amendment protects people's "houses, papers, and effects" against unreasonable searches.

What Was Lost

The story starts in a constitutional republic. These are the safeguards it had, and how each one was lost.

  • Safeguard: Voters who asked, "Does the constitution allow it?"

    How it was lost: In the hard years they asked only, "Will it keep us safe?" Once that was the only question, every wall was up for trade.

  • Safeguard: Knowing what the walls were for

    How it was lost: The seventh-grade lesson on the constitution was cut for test drills, so a generation grew up never learning why the walls were thick.

  • Safeguard: Privacy at home

    How it was lost: Every house had to cut a window facing the street, "just" so the night watch could see that all was well. By the end, the walls might as well have been glass.

  • Safeguard: Trust between neighbors

    How it was lost: The watch paid neighbors and coworkers in coal and promotions to write reports. Everyone knew some were informing, and nobody knew which ones.

  • Safeguard: Clubs, unions, and churches that belong to their members

    How it was lost: The chess club, the choir, the union, and the football league were closed and replaced by Party versions; a Party officer took notes in the chapel.

  • Safeguard: A free press

    How it was lost: Two quarreling newspapers became one Party paper that agreed with itself about everything.

  • Safeguard: Parents raising their own children

    How it was lost: The Lantern Youth taught children to admire a boy who reported his father, and teachers asked what parents said at dinner.

  • Safeguard: Equal treatment under the law

    How it was lost: Painted loyalty cards decided homes, jobs, and schooling, and the color passed from parents to children.

  • Safeguard: An honest record of the past

    How it was lost: The town chronicle was rewritten, old newspapers vanished, and a fallen councilman disappeared from a photograph.

  • Safeguard: Freedom of conscience

    How it was lost: People learned to wear two faces, one for the street and one kept so far inside that they sometimes forgot it was there.

What the Story Shows

  • In the story: How the Unity Party won every office in Linden is a story of its own

    In real life: Political theorist Hannah Arendt's The Origins of Totalitarianism (1951) argued that Nazi Germany and Stalin's Soviet Union were a new kind of rule: not just one-party dictatorships, but states that used ideology and terror to reach into every part of life. How such parties take power is told in this series' fascism and communism stories.

  • In the story: Nobody announces who has said yes

    In real life: By 1989, East Germany's Stasi had about 189,000 unofficial collaborators, about one for every 90 citizens, alongside about 91,000 full-time staff. Collaborators passed on intimate details about colleagues, friends, and fellow pupils (Stasi Records Archive).

  • In the story: The Party opens its own: the Unity Chess Circle, the Unity Choir, the Unity Workers' Front

    In real life: Nazi Germany called this Gleichschaltung, "coordination." All labor unions were abolished in May 1933 and replaced by the German Labor Front, and sports teams, music groups, and craft associations organized under other parties or unions were disbanded (U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum).

  • In the story: Every club belongs to the Party

    In real life: The UN Commission of Inquiry (2014) found that in North Korea virtually all social activities are controlled by the Workers' Party of Korea, through associations citizens are obliged to join, and that citizens are rewarded for reporting on one another.

  • In the story: The children join the Lantern Youth. It's free, there are summer camps and brass bands

    In real life: The Hitler Youth grew from about 100,000 members in January 1933 to more than 2 million by the end of that year and 5.4 million by 1937 (USHMM). A December 1, 1936 law made it the state youth organization, and a regulation of March 25, 1939 made membership compulsory for ages 10 to 18, with criminal penalties for refusing (German Historical Institute).

  • In the story: Little Tomas, a brave boy who told the watch that his own father was hiding grain

    In real life: Soviet schools and the Young Pioneers honored Pavlik Morozov, a 13-year-old killed in the village of Gerasimovka in September 1932, who was said to have denounced his father and been murdered by relatives. Historians who studied the case, Yuri Druzhnikov and Catriona Kelly (Comrade Pavlik, 2005), concluded the official story was largely myth.

  • In the story: Every door gets a small painted card: gold, gray, or black

    In real life: North Korea's songbun system sorts people by family background and loyalty into three broad classes, core, wavering, and hostile, subdivided into about 51 categories (Robert Collins, Marked for Life, HRNK, 2012). The UN Commission of Inquiry found it shaped where people live, their jobs, schooling, food, and marriage, and that Pyongyang is reserved for the most loyal.

  • In the story: The color passes from parents to children like a family name

    In real life: The UN Commission of Inquiry found that North Korean authorities have sent entire families, up to the third generation, to political prison camps for one relative's political crime, and estimated that 80,000 to 120,000 political prisoners were held in four large camps in 2014.

  • In the story: A former councilman who fell out of favor disappears from the photograph

    In real life: Nikolai Yezhov ran the Soviet secret police during the Great Purge, then was shot in 1940. Soviet retouchers later erased him from a 1937 photograph of him walking with Stalin beside the Moscow-Volga Canal (Newseum; David King, The Commissar Vanishes, 1997).

  • In the story: The word "free" is painted on banners everywhere

    In real life: George Orwell's novel Nineteen Eighty-Four (published June 8, 1949) imagined a state that shrinks the language itself ("Newspeak") so that disloyal thoughts become hard to express, and that trains people to accept contradictions ("doublethink"). It is fiction, but it drew on the real totalitarian states of its time.

  • In the story: They learn to wear two faces

    In real life: The UN Commission of Inquiry found "an almost complete denial" of freedom of thought, conscience, and religion in North Korea, and an indoctrination system that starts in childhood.

  • In the story: They walk into the watch house itself

    In real life: Citizens in Erfurt occupied the local Stasi office on December 4, 1989, and crowds entered Stasi headquarters on Normannenstrasse in East Berlin on January 15, 1990 (German Historical Institute).

  • In the story: Anyone may read their own folder, and learn the real name of anyone who wrote about them

    In real life: Germany's Stasi Records Act of December 20, 1991 opened the files to the people they described starting January 2, 1992, with the right to learn the real names behind informers' code names when the records show them clearly. More than 1.5 million people have seen their files (Federal Archives).

In real history

Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union under Stalin are the classic cases historians call totalitarian, from opposite ends of the political spectrum. East Germany ran one of the largest informer networks ever recorded, and a UN inquiry found in 2014 that North Korea's state controls nearly every part of its citizens' lives.

You Decide

What draws people to it

  • An end to chaos. Totalitarian movements rose after World War I and the Great Depression, when street fighting, unemployment, and weak governments left many people longing for order, and they promised it.
  • Security. East Germany's 1949 constitution guaranteed every citizen the right to work and a living (Article 15), a promise of a job that many citizens valued.
  • Belonging. Youth groups, rallies, and one shared cause gave many people, especially the young, a sense of community. The Hitler Youth grew from about 100,000 members to more than 2 million in 1933 alone, years before membership was made compulsory.
  • Real belief. Hannah Arendt observed in 1951 that totalitarian movements, unlike many older tyrannies, rested on genuine mass support while it lasted. Many people were not only afraid; they believed in the cause.

What it costs

  • No private life. About 91,000 Stasi staff and about 189,000 unofficial informers watched a country of about 16 million, and friends and family members were among the informers.
  • Punishment by birth. North Korea's songbun ties a person's home, job, schooling, and food to a family background they cannot change, and the UN found crimes against humanity in 2014.
  • No way to fix mistakes. With every club, union, church, and newspaper run by the party, there was no independent place to warn of a disaster or to organize a peaceful change.
  • The damage outlasts the regime. Long after 1990, East Germans were still reading their files and learning which friends and relatives had reported on them.

Linden traded one window for safety, and each step after that seemed small. Where would you draw the line on what a government may know about you, and which groups in your own life, a team, a club, a congregation, a group of friends, would you want kept free of any government's control?

Compare totalitarianism with authoritarianism and fascism on Modern Systems of Government, read the Bill of Rights that protects speech, worship, assembly, and the home, and see how the Constitution divides power so no one part can take it all on Safeguards Against Tyranny.

Why a republic is easy to lose and hard to win back

See all the stories in Government through Stories

Last updated: