The U.S. Government

Because democracy only works when we understand it

An illustration of four wealthy men in a wood-paneled room around a round table covered with maps, papers, and ashtrays: one in a pinstripe suit points with a cigar, while others study a map of Europe marked with dollar signs and arrows
Government through Stories: Oligarchy

The Long Table, the Golden Book, and the Closing of the Door

A harbor town's council chairs are open to anyone, until a few rich families write the rules for who may sit in them. Nobody breaks a law, and the elections never stop.

Political system6 minute read

The Long Table, the Golden Book, and the Closing of the Door

Imagine a harbor town called Port Halloran. The town is a republic. Its constitution sets up a council of forty members who meet at the Long Table in the town hall, and every two years the voters choose who sits in those forty chairs.

The rule for running is simple. Anyone twenty-five or older who lives in Port Halloran can put their name on the ballot. Fishermen have sat at the Long Table. So have a baker, a schoolteacher, and a ropemaker. The chairs belong to the town, not to the people sitting in them (open office).

Three families grow rich in the shipping trade: the Ashcombes, the Verrells, and the Penroses. Their ships carry salt fish south and bring back cloth, spices, and coin. They build fine houses on the hill above the harbor.

They aren't villains. They pay for a new seawall when the council can't. They put a new roof on the school. When a storm sinks half the fishing fleet, the Verrells lend the money to rebuild it. The town grows richer than it has ever been.

And the people begin to trust them.

Running for the council starts to cost money. Handbills must be printed, halls rented, and lamps lit for evening meetings. The families are glad to help the candidates they like (campaign money). Soon voters stop asking, "Who would serve all of us best?" They ask, "Who has the backing to win?"

At the school, the hour once spent reading the town's constitution goes to bookkeeping and navigation, which the shipping houses say young people really need. A generation grows up knowing how to balance a ledger, but not why the Long Table has forty chairs, or who those chairs belong to.

Then comes a lean year. The treasury is empty, and the council can't pay its clerks or its harbor guards. The families offer a loan. As security, the town pledges its shipyard, the biggest business in Port Halloran. When the loan comes due, the treasury still can't pay, so the families keep the shipyard. It is worth many times what they lent (a sale to insiders).

Ah, but nobody else was allowed to make an offer. The families wrote the terms of the loan themselves.

The mayor who signed the deal faces a hard election that fall. The families pay for his campaign, and he wins.

Nobody breaks a single rule. The families simply start writing them.

The first new rule seems sensible. Anyone who runs for the council must pay a filing fee, to keep out pranksters and cranks. The fee is a month's wages for a fisherman. For a shipping family, it is pocket change (a fee to run for office).

The second rule sounds reasonable too. Council members handle the town's money, so each one must own property worth a set amount, as a guarantee of good conduct (a property requirement for office).

The third rule sounds noble. Council members should serve out of duty, not for pay, so the small salary that came with each chair is ended (unpaid office). The families call it public service. But a fisherman who spends his days at the Long Table can't spend them on the water, so fishermen stop running.

When old Mr. Ashcombe dies in the middle of his term, the council chooses his son to finish it. The son knows the work. He grew up hearing it discussed at the dinner table. When the next Verrell chair opens, a Verrell nephew fills it (seats passed down in families).

The Harbor Gazette, the town's only newspaper, is losing money. The Penroses buy it and keep it running. It still prints the ship arrivals, the weather, and the price of fish. It just stops printing stories about the shipping families (a captured press).

Last, the council makes a book. To run for office, a candidate's name must be written in the Register of Citizens in Good Standing, a heavy volume with gold-edged pages kept in the clerk's office. To get your name in, two council members must sign for you (the Golden Book).

For a few years, they sign for friends, business partners, and sons-in-law. Then the council votes that no new names may be added, except by a two-thirds vote of the council itself (the closing).

The book is closed.

Port Halloran doesn't fall apart. In many ways it runs better than ever. The families plan for the next thirty years instead of the next election. The harbor is dredged, the lighthouse rebuilt, and the town's ships trade in ports the old council had never heard of. There are no shouting matches at the Long Table and no wild promises. Visitors call Port Halloran the steadiest town on the coast.

But the fishermen's dock rots while the shipping wharf gets new stone. The harbor tax goes up on small boats and down on large ships. The council lends the town's savings to the families' own counting houses at low interest. None of it is illegal. The people who make the laws are the people the laws help.

Nell Tarrant is a fisherman's daughter who knows the harbor better than anyone at the Long Table. She knows where the channel silts up and which pilings will give way in the next storm. She decides to run for the council.

She can't pay the fee. She owns no property worth the required amount. She couldn't afford to serve without pay anyway. And when she asks the clerk to put her name in the book, he tells her, kindly, that the book is closed.

She writes a letter to the Gazette. It isn't printed.

Elections are still held every two years. The ballots are still printed, and people still line up to vote. There are even close races, an Ashcombe against a Penrose, or a Verrell against another Verrell.

But every name on the ballot comes from the same book, and the book belongs to the same few families.

Fewer people bother to vote. Whoever wins, the hill wins.

One evening Nell walks past the town hall. Through the tall windows she can see the Long Table and its forty chairs, exactly where they have always been. The constitution still hangs on the wall. Not one word of it has changed.

The chairs never moved. Only the door did.

Nobody stormed the town hall. The door was closed one reasonable rule at a time, by the people already inside.

Port Halloran is rich, steady, and well run. Nell Tarrant still has her vote. She just can't find a name on the ballot that isn't from the hill.

The Real Lesson

This story isn't saying that wealth is wicked, that rich families can't serve the public well, or that everyone who funds a candidate is plotting to take over. The families in Port Halloran built real things, and the town they ran was peaceful and prosperous.

History backs that up. After Venice closed its Great Council, it stayed a rich and stable republic for five hundred years. Some thinkers, going back to Aristotle, have argued that a few experienced, well-trained leaders can govern with a longer view than a crowd chasing the next election.

The real issue is access.

When only a few families can afford to run, can win the backing to win, and can get their names into the book, elections stop being a real choice. Voters still pick between candidates, but the candidates have already been picked for them.

And power that doesn't have to compete for everyone's vote slowly starts serving the people who hold it. The dock rots while the wharf gets new stone, not because anyone is cruel, but because nobody at the table has to answer to the fishermen.

The real lesson is this: power that only a few can reach stops answering to everyone else, even when the elections continue. Open competition, and an equal chance for any citizen to run and to serve, are what keep the door open.

Where the Door Closed, and Where It Opened

In 1297, Venice began the Serrata, or "closing," of its Great Council. Over the next generation, membership became hereditary, limited to the sons of families already in it; by 1300 the council had more than 1,100 members, about 1 percent of the city. From the 1500s, the births and marriages of noble families were recorded in registers later called the Golden Book. The republic lasted until May 12, 1797, when, under pressure from Napoleon's army, the Great Council voted 512 to 30, with 5 abstaining, to end it.

In 1995, Russia's government borrowed from a few private banks against shares of its biggest companies ("loans for shares"). When the loans went unpaid, the banks kept the companies: a 51 percent stake in Norilsk Nickel went for about $170 million, and 45 percent of Yukos for about $159 million. The same bankers financed Boris Yeltsin's 1996 reelection. Then the state turned on them: Vladimir Gusinsky and Boris Berezovsky left Russia in 2000, and Mikhail Khodorkovsky, Yukos's owner, was arrested on October 25, 2003, and spent ten years in prison.

Some republics opened the door instead. Britain's property qualification for members of Parliament was abolished in 1858, and members were first paid in 1911, both demands of the Chartists' People's Charter of 1838. The U.S. Constitution of 1787 set no property requirement to serve in Congress, provided that members "shall receive a Compensation for their Services," and declared that "No Title of Nobility shall be granted by the United States."

James Madison wrote in The Federalist No. 39 (1788) that Venice was called a republic even though power there was held "by a small body of hereditary nobles." He argued that a true republic draws its officials "from the great body of the society, not from an inconsiderable proportion, or a favored class of it."

What Was Lost

The story starts in a constitutional republic. These are the safeguards it had, and how each one was lost.

  • Safeguard: Voters who asked, "Who would serve all of us best?"

    How it was lost: They came to ask only who had the backing to win. Once the families paid for the campaigns, the families' candidates were the only ones who looked like winners.

  • Safeguard: Schools that taught the constitution

    How it was lost: The civics hour went to bookkeeping and navigation, and a generation grew up not knowing that the forty chairs belonged to the town.

  • Safeguard: Public property sold fairly and in the open

    How it was lost: The town pledged its shipyard for a loan written by the lenders themselves, and the families kept it for a fraction of its worth with no other bidders.

  • Safeguard: Open office: any adult resident could run

    How it was lost: A filing fee and a property requirement, each sensible on its own, priced ordinary people out of the race.

  • Safeguard: Paid public service

    How it was lost: The council salary was ended in the name of duty, so only people who didn't need to work could afford to serve.

  • Safeguard: Seats filled by the voters

    How it was lost: When a member died, the council handed the chair to his son or nephew, and family seats became the custom.

  • Safeguard: A free press

    How it was lost: One of the families bought the only newspaper. It kept printing the news, but not news about the families.

  • Safeguard: Elections with a real choice

    How it was lost: The council closed the register of who could run. Ballots were still printed, but every name came from the same book.

What the Story Shows

  • In the story: The chairs belong to the town, not to the people sitting in them

    In real life: Aristotle, writing in the 300s BC, sorted governments by who rules and for whom: "oligarchy has in view the interest of the wealthy," not the common good, and arises "when men of property have the government in their hands" (Politics, Book III).

  • In the story: The families are glad to help the candidates they like

    In real life: In late 1996, Boris Berezovsky told the Financial Times that a group of top bankers, himself included, had joined forces before Russia's presidential election to keep the Communists from returning to power, and claimed the group controlled half of Russia's economy, a figure historians call an overstatement. They gave millions to Boris Yeltsin's campaign, and he won the July 3, 1996 runoff with about 54 percent to the Communist candidate's 40 percent.

  • In the story: The families keep the shipyard

    In real life: In Russia's "loans for shares" auctions, held from November 17 to December 28, 1995, banks lent the government money against stakes in 12 major companies and kept the stakes when the loans went unpaid. A 51 percent stake in Norilsk Nickel went for about $170.1 million, and 45 percent of the oil company Yukos for about $159 million. Critics called the auctions rigged: in several, the bank running the auction also won it.

  • In the story: A generation grows up knowing how to balance a ledger

    In real life: In 2022, U.S. eighth graders' civics scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress fell for the first time since the test began in 1998. In Venice, by contrast, young nobles were trained for office from youth, and from 1319 the sons of council families joined the Great Council automatically at 25.

  • In the story: A filing fee and a property requirement

    In real life: Britain required members of Parliament to own property of a set value until 1858. Abolishing that requirement was one of the six demands of the Chartists' People's Charter of 1838.

  • In the story: The small salary that came with each chair is ended

    In real life: Members of Britain's House of Commons were unpaid until 1911, when Parliament voted a salary of Β£400 a year. Until then, a member needed private income or outside backing to afford a seat. The U.S. Constitution of 1787 provided that members of Congress "shall receive a Compensation for their Services."

  • In the story: The council chooses his son to finish it

    In real life: Venice's 1297 law (the Serrata, or "closing") limited Great Council membership to men who had served in the past four years or whose fathers' line had served. By about 1323, membership was in effect hereditary.

  • In the story: The Penroses buy the Gazette

    In real life: In 1990s Russia, two of the same bankers, Boris Berezovsky and Vladimir Gusinsky, controlled the country's two largest national television networks, ORT and NTV. After 2000 the tables turned: in April 2001, the state-controlled company Gazprom took over Vladimir Gusinsky's NTV, Russia's main independent television network.

  • In the story: The Register of Citizens in Good Standing

    In real life: The Golden Book (Libro d'Oro) was the register of Venice's noble families, whose births and marriages were recorded from the 1500s. Only those in it could sit in the Great Council. New families were let in only rarely, mostly during costly wars, in return for large payments to the state.

  • In the story: No new names may be added, except by a vote of the council itself

    In real life: In 404 BC, after Athens lost the Peloponnesian War, Sparta installed an oligarchy known as the Thirty Tyrants, which limited full citizenship to about 3,000 chosen men. Isocrates and Aristotle report that about 1,500 people were executed without trial before democrats led by Thrasybulus overthrew the Thirty in 403 BC.

  • In the story: Visitors call Port Halloran the steadiest town on the coast

    In real life: Venice's closed council kept the republic stable for five centuries. Plots against it, such as Bajamonte Tiepolo's in 1310, failed; after that one the government created the Council of Ten to guard the state. Doge Marino Faliero was beheaded in 1355 for plotting to seize power.

  • In the story: Elections are still held every two years

    In real life: Venice's nobles held constant elections among themselves. From 1268, the doge was chosen in ten rounds that alternated drawing lots and voting, a method meant to keep any one family from controlling the result. Every candidate, though, came from the same closed council.

In real history

Venice after 1297, the Thirty Tyrants of Athens in 404 BC, and Russia's bankers of the 1990s are all classic oligarchies. In Venice the few governed steadily for five hundred years; in Athens they lasted eight months; in Russia they were soon brought under the control of a stronger state.

You Decide

What draws people to it

  • Stability. After the Great Council closed in 1297, Venice remained a wealthy, independent republic until 1797, and every attempt to seize it from inside, in 1310 and 1355, failed.
  • Experience and a long view. Families who expect to govern for generations can plan for decades; Venice's nobles trained for public office from youth, and its doges served for life under a sworn written oath limiting their powers (the promissione).
  • Checks among the few. Venice spread power across councils and chose its doge through ten rounds of lots and votes (from 1268) so that no one family could take over, and Aristotle counted rule by the best few for the common good (aristocracy) among the good forms of government.
  • A defense against something worse. Russia's bankers said they joined forces in 1996 to keep the Communists from returning to power, and their supporters argued they kept the market reforms alive.

What it costs

  • A closed door. Venice's Great Council held about 1 percent of the city's people; everyone else, however able, was shut out of office for five hundred years.
  • Rule for the rulers. Aristotle defined oligarchy as government in "the interest of the wealthy," not "the common good of all," and the few tend to write rules that favor themselves.
  • Public wealth sold cheap. In 1995, stakes in 12 of Russia's biggest companies went to a few insiders in auctions they helped run, Yukos for about $159 million.
  • No protection when the few fall out. The Thirty Tyrants of Athens executed about 1,500 people in eight months, and Russia's oligarchs were themselves exiled or jailed once a stronger state turned on them, Khodorkovsky for ten years.

Venice's closed council kept a rich republic steady for five hundred years, and Russia's bankers said they were saving their country from something worse. But in both, ordinary people had little say in who governed them. Is a well-run government by a few better than a messier one open to all? And what rules would keep the chairs open to someone like Nell?

See how oligarchy compares with other systems on Modern Systems of Government, read how the Constitution spreads power so no small group can hold all of it on Safeguards Against Tyranny, and learn how open elections are run today on How Elections Work.

Why a republic is easy to lose and hard to win back

See all the stories in Government through Stories

Last updated: