The U.S. Government

Because democracy only works when we understand it

Hundreds of Chinese soldiers in identical green uniforms, caps, and red collar tabs fill the stands of an arena in Peking, photographed during President Nixon's 1972 visit to Mao's China
Government through Stories: Communism

The Orchard, the Promise, and the Wall That Kept Everyone In

Communism doesn’t always break down a republic’s door. Sometimes it knocks politely, holding flowers, and promises an orchard where everyone gets what they need.

Economic system7 minute read

The Orchard, the Promise, and the Wall That Kept Everyone In

Communism doesn’t always break down a republic’s door. Sometimes it knocks politely, holding flowers.

Picture a town with a large orchard. Every family owns its own trees. Some families have big, old trees that produce more apples than they can use. Others have only a few young trees and struggle to get through the winter. Some families are comfortable; others are not. The town has an elected council to keep the peace, and every council member has sworn to uphold the town’s constitution.

Nobody’s basket is the same size. And for some people, that feels deeply unfair.

One day, a charming stranger arrives at the harvest dance. He doesn’t talk about taking power. He talks about fairness.

“Why should one family’s cellar be full while the family next door goes hungry?” he asks. “Why should some families have so much while others have so little? Take down the fences. Pool the apples. Everyone will get what they need.”

It is a beautiful promise. And many of the kindest people in town believe it first. They are the ones who cannot stand to see their neighbors hungry. They aren't looking for a revolution. They just want things to be fair.

The stranger's political party begins organizing. It doesn't win every seat in the next election, but it wins enough to become the largest party on the council. Then it asks for just one important responsibility: control of the orchard gate and the people who guard it.

After all, someone has to make sure everyone follows the new rules.

The party establishes a Committee to collect the apples and distribute them equally. At first, it sounds reasonable. But the families with the largest trees don't want to surrender what they spent years planting and maintaining. The Committee calls them selfish and greedy. It declares that the orchard belongs to everyone and takes their trees without fair compensation.

When the town newspaper asks who gave the Committee the authority to do this, the Committee calls the paper an enemy of the people. It claims the newspaper is spreading lies on behalf of wealthy families and shuts it down.

Other political parties object. They remind the council that the Committee has no right to ignore the constitution. But the ruling party fills the town square with angry crowds, accusing its opponents of standing against equality. Council members begin to fear for their families, their positions, and their safety.

One by one, they back down.

The constitution is still written in the town hall. It just doesn't mean much anymore.

There is still an election every year. There are still speeches, rallies, and ballots. But the opposition has been silenced, its leaders threatened or imprisoned, and its ability to compete destroyed. Eventually, there is only one name on the ballot.

The people still get to vote. They just don't get to choose.

Then something unexpected happens. The orchard begins producing fewer apples.

Nobody takes the same pride in pruning a tree that no longer belongs to them. Nobody wakes up before dawn to work harder when the reward is the same whether they work hard or hardly work at all. The most experienced growers have been pushed out, and the Committee has replaced local knowledge with government instructions.

The harvest shrinks. Then it shrinks again.

But the Committee refuses to admit that its system is failing. Instead, it blames hoarders, troublemakers, and saboteurs. Families who save a few apples for themselves are accused of stealing from the community. People who criticize the Committee are accused of trying to destroy the town.

Some are arrested. Others are sent away. There are no independent judges left to challenge the accusations, and no free newspaper to tell the town what is really happening.

The families are told that the problem isn't the system. The problem is that people aren't obeying it well enough.

Every family now receives the same basket. It is just a little smaller every year.

Except for the Committee. Somehow, its members never seem to go hungry. They have the best houses, the best food, and the best access to everything the orchard still produces. The equality they promised has become a privilege reserved for the people in charge.

Eventually, some families decide they have had enough. They want to leave the orchard and find somewhere they can own their own trees, make their own decisions, and keep what they earn.

But the Committee has a solution for that, too.

It builds a wall.

Not to keep outsiders from getting in, but to keep the families from getting out. The people who were promised freedom from inequality are now prisoners of the system that promised to save them.

And here's the hardest part: by this point, how do the families take their town back?

The Committee controls the guards. It controls the newspapers. It controls the courts. It controls the distribution of food, the jobs, and the property. It decides which political parties are allowed to exist and which voices are permitted to be heard.

The families can no longer simply vote the Committee out. They cannot organize freely, challenge its decisions in court, or even reliably tell one another what is happening. The very institutions that were supposed to protect the people have become tools for protecting the government from the people.

Removing that kind of power is no longer a matter of winning an election. It may require dismantling an entire system of control, and the people who benefit from that system have every reason to prevent it.

It started with a promise that sounded like kindness, and for many people, it was. Nobody wants their neighbors to go hungry. Nobody wants a society where opportunity is determined entirely by the family into which someone is born.

But there is a difference between helping people and giving the government control over everything they own, produce, say, and do.

A promise to make everyone equal requires someone with the power to enforce it. And when that power has no meaningful limits, the people enforcing equality can become the most privileged people of all.

The fences came down.

The Committee took the keys.

And a wall went up.

The Real Lesson

The lesson isn't that a society shouldn't care about the poor, help struggling families, or work toward greater opportunity. A decent society should do all three.

The lesson is that good intentions are not a substitute for limits on government power. When a government claims the authority to decide what people can own, what they can earn, what they can say, and where they can go, it has taken on far more power than any group of elected officials should possess.

And once that power is concentrated in the hands of one political party, getting it back can be nearly impossible. Elections mean little when there is no real opposition. Laws mean little when courts cannot enforce them. Rights mean little when the government controls the people responsible for protecting them.

A constitutional republic is designed to prevent exactly this kind of concentration of power. It protects private property, free speech, independent courts, political competition, and the right of citizens to hold their leaders accountable. These protections aren't obstacles to fairness. They are safeguards against tyranny.

The real lesson is this: A government powerful enough to give everyone everything is also powerful enough to take everything away. And when the people lose the ability to hold that government accountable, they may discover that the power they surrendered in the name of equality is the very power they need to regain their freedom.

Oaths and Checks That Held

Finland faced the same moment in 1948. Its Communist interior minister, Yrjö Leino, controlled the State Police, and in 1945 he had handed about 20 people over to the Soviet Union without any legal extradition. That spring, after the communist takeover in Czechoslovakia, many Finns feared a coup of their own. President Juho Kusti Paasikivi, the Social Democrats, and army chief Aarne Sihvo took precautions, though historians still debate how real the threat was.

On May 20, 1948, Finland's parliament voted 81 to 61 to censure Leino. He refused to resign, and on May 22 President Paasikivi dismissed him. The Communists lost ground in that July's election, the State Police was abolished at the end of the year and replaced by a new Security Police, and Finland stayed a democratic republic.

Czechoslovakia's leaders made the opposite choice that same year. In February 1948, twelve non-communist ministers resigned, hoping to force early elections, but on February 25 President Edvard Beneš accepted their resignations and approved a government led by the Communists. By June the country had held a single-list election, and Beneš had resigned rather than sign its new constitution. Every federal official in the United States takes an oath of office to the Constitution, not to a party.

What Was Lost

The story starts in a constitutional republic. These are the safeguards it had, and how each one was lost.

  • Safeguard: Voters who asked, "Does the constitution allow it?"

    How it was lost: They asked only whether the promise was fair, and never who would hold the power to make it fair, or how they would take that power back.

  • Safeguard: Power divided among parties

    How it was lost: One party took the keys to the orchard gate. In Czechoslovakia, the Communists ran the Interior Ministry, including the police.

  • Safeguard: No property taken without fair payment

    How it was lost: The big-tree families' trees were taken and pooled under the Committee.

  • Safeguard: A free press

    How it was lost: The paper asked who gave the Committee its authority, so the Committee called it an enemy of the people and shut it down.

  • Safeguard: Officials sworn to the constitution

    How it was lost: Afraid for their families, their positions, and their safety, the council members backed down one by one.

  • Safeguard: Free elections

    How it was lost: The election still came every year, with only one name on the ballot.

  • Safeguard: Fair trials

    How it was lost: When the harvest shrank, critics were blamed as hoarders and saboteurs, arrested, or sent away, with no independent judges left to hear them.

  • Safeguard: The same rules for everyone

    How it was lost: Every family got the same shrinking basket, except the Committee, whose members had the best houses, the best food, and the best access to everything.

  • Safeguard: Freedom to leave

    How it was lost: A wall went up, not to keep anyone out, but to keep everyone in.

  • Safeguard: A written constitution

    How it was lost: It was still written in the town hall, and there was still an election every year. It just didn't mean much anymore.

What the Story Shows

  • In the story: "Pool the apples. Everyone will get what they need."

    In real life: Karl Marx wrote in 1875, "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs!" In The Communist Manifesto (1848), he and Friedrich Engels wrote that their theory "may be summed up in the single sentence: Abolition of private property."

  • In the story: It wins enough to become the largest party on the council

    In real life: Czechoslovakia, the only Central European country that stayed a parliamentary democracy for the whole period between the world wars, held a free election in May 1946. The Communist Party won about 38 percent, the largest share, and its leader, Klement Gottwald, became prime minister that July.

  • In the story: Just one important responsibility: control of the orchard gate and the people who guard it

    In real life: Czechoslovakia's Communists controlled the Ministry of the Interior, including the police.

  • In the story: The party establishes a Committee

    In real life: In What Is to Be Done? (1902), Vladimir Lenin argued that the workers' struggle had to be led by "a strong organisation of revolutionaries" made up of professional revolutionaries, the model for the Communist Party's rule.

  • In the story: The big-tree families are called selfish and greedy, and their trees are taken without fair compensation

    In real life: In December 1929, Joseph Stalin announced a policy of "eliminating the kulaks as a class," the better-off farmers. About 1.8 million people were deported in 1930 and 1931, and the Soviet Union forced farmers onto collective farms.

  • In the story: The square fills with angry crowds, and one by one, the council backs down

    In real life: In February 1948, twelve non-communist ministers resigned. Communist "action committees" took over ministries, an armed workers' militia appeared in the streets, and on February 25 President Beneš accepted a Communist-led government. On March 10, Foreign Minister Jan Masaryk was found dead in the courtyard of the Foreign Ministry; the cause is still disputed, and Czech police concluded in 2004 that he was likely murdered.

  • In the story: The people still get to vote. They just don't get to choose.

    In real life: On May 30, 1948, Czechoslovak voters were offered a single list of candidates, which officially won 89 percent. The only way to vote against it was to cast a blank ballot.

  • In the story: The orchard begins producing fewer apples

    In real life: Forced collectivization caused a catastrophic famine in 1932 and 1933 that killed roughly 6 to 9 million people across the Soviet Union, including about 3.9 million in Ukraine, known as the Holodomor. China's Great Leap Forward (1958 to 1962) led to a famine that killed tens of millions, with estimates from about 15 to 45 million.

  • In the story: The Committee blames hoarders and saboteurs

    In real life: In the 1928 Shakhty trial, the first major Soviet show trial, about 53 engineers and managers were accused of "wrecking" (sabotage). A law of August 7, 1932, made stealing collective farm property, even a few ears of grain, punishable by death or at least ten years in prison.

  • In the story: Some are arrested. Others are sent away.

    In real life: Some 18 million people passed through the Soviet Gulag, the system of forced-labor camps, between 1929 and 1953, according to historian Anne Applebaum.

  • In the story: Somehow, its members never seem to go hungry

    In real life: Soviet party officials, the nomenklatura, had special shops, better housing, and country houses closed to ordinary citizens, as Michael Voslensky described in Nomenklatura (1984).

  • In the story: A wall, not to keep outsiders from getting in, but to keep the families from getting out

    In real life: About 2.7 million people left East Germany between 1949 and 1961. On August 13, 1961, East Germany began building the Berlin Wall to stop them. At least 140 people were killed there before it fell on November 9, 1989.

In real history

Communist parties took power in Russia in 1917, across most of Eastern Europe after World War II, and in China, North Korea, Vietnam, Cuba, and Laos. Communist rule across Eastern Europe was overthrown in 1989, and the Soviet Union dissolved in December 1991. Today communist parties rule China, Cuba, Laos, and Vietnam, and North Korea is a one-party state that dropped the word "communism" from its constitution in 2009.

You Decide

What draws people to it

  • The ideal itself: a world without rich and poor, where no one goes hungry while a neighbor's cellar is full. That promise has drawn followers on every continent since Marx and Engels wrote it down in 1848.
  • Fast industrial growth. The Soviet Union's Five-Year Plans, starting in 1928, set out to turn a country of farmers into an industrial power within a few years, building factories, dams, and steel mills.
  • Mass literacy. In 1897, only about one in four people in the Russian Empire could read; by the 1950s, nearly every Soviet citizen could. Cuba's 1961 literacy campaign cut illiteracy from about 24 percent to about 4 percent.
  • Security. Communist states promised every citizen a job, housing, and medical care, guarantees that drew people who had known only poverty.

What it costs

  • Famine. Collectivization in the Soviet Union and the Great Leap Forward in China killed millions of people.
  • Prisons and camps. About 18 million people passed through the Soviet Gulag, many for things they said or for being called saboteurs.
  • One-party rule. Once the party held the police, the press, and the ballot, voters had no peaceful way to change course.
  • Walls. East Germany walled in its own people, and at least 140 died trying to cross the Berlin Wall.

Nearly every republic argues about how much to help families with small harvests, and many help them without tearing down the fences. Where is the line between a town that shares and a Committee that owns everything? Who should hold the keys to the gate, and if the wrong people ever got them, how would you get them back?

See how communism compares with socialism, capitalism, and other systems on Modern Systems of Government, and how the Constitution keeps any one party or person from taking total control on Safeguards Against Tyranny.

Why a republic is easy to lose and hard to win back

See all the stories in Government through Stories

Last updated: